The case – The Silence After the Funeral
Bilal, 29, came in describing “stress”, trouble sleeping, a short fuse at work, a growing distance from his wife that he couldn’t explain. Three sessions in, a detail slipped out almost by accident: his father had passed away two years earlier, and he hadn’t cried once. Not at the funeral, not since. He remembered standing at the graveside, feeling something enormous rising in his chest, and physically clenching his jaw until it passed. “If I started, I don’t know what would happen,” he said. “And everyone was looking at me to hold it together, I’m the eldest son.” Since then, he described feeling “flat,” except for sudden bursts of irritability that seemed to come from nowhere, snapping at his wife over small things, then feeling ashamed afterward without understanding why.
Where this comes from – The Lesson Boys Learn Before They Can Spell It
Most men I see grew up hearing some version of “mard rotay nahi hain”, men don’t feel pain. It’s rarely said with cruelty; it’s usually said to prepare boys for a hard world, often by parents who themselves were never allowed to grieve or feel afraid. But the message that actually lands in a child’s mind isn’t “be resilient.” It’s “your pain is a liability, hide it, or you’ll lose respect, safety, or love.” Over years, this doesn’t just suppress crying. It teaches the nervous system to route every vulnerable emotion, grief, fear, hurt, disappointment, through the one channel that’s socially permitted for men: anger. Bilal wasn’t an angry person by nature. He was a grieving person who had never been taught another way out.
What it costs – When Anger Is the Only Language Left
Suppressed emotion doesn’t disappear, it resurfaces sideways. In Bilal’s case: unexplained irritability, disconnection from his wife or any close relation (who described “living with someone who’s present but not really there”), and physical tension his doctor couldn’t explain. This pattern, multiplied across a lifetime, is a major reason men are diagnosed with depression less often than women despite similar suffering, the presentation looks like anger or numbness, not sadness, so it’s frequently missed by the people around them, any form of unhealthy habit or addiction, and sometimes by the men themselves. It also quietly damages intimacy: a partner (or any close relation) can’t feel close to someone who’s defended against being truly known, even when the defense is unconscious.
What actually helps – Learning to Feel Without Apologizing
Therapy isn’t about becoming “soft” or performing emotion that isn’t there, that framing itself is often part of what keeps men away from help. The real work is widening the emotional range someone has access to, so anger isn’t the only feeling that gets a voice. For Bilal, this meant slowly, safely revisiting the grief he’d frozen at the graveside, not by forcing tears, but by finally being allowed to talk about his father without an audience judging whether he was “holding it together.” Over several months, his irritability decreased on its own, almost as a side effect, once the underlying grief had somewhere to go besides out sideways at people he loved.
Illustrative case, not a real client. Details are composited from common presentations.
#MensMentalHealth #MardKoDardNahiHota #MasculinityInPakistan #GriefAndMen #EmotionalHealthPK